Mental Barriers Hamper Obese Women
Tailored programs could help curb aversion and improve adherence to the weight loss plans.
For arachnophobes, it’s difficult to kill a spider as it scurries across the floor. Those who are scared to fly might not ever set foot on a plane. While nothing physically stops people with these aversions, a mental barrier can keep them from the task at hand.
Researchers from the Center for Obesity Research and Education and the department of kinesiology at Temple University found that obese women face a significant number of barriers when it comes to exercise—more so than those of normal weight.
“This is the first time we’ve been able to systematically look at what stops obese women from getting the activity they need,” said Melissa Napolitano, Ph.D., associate professor of kinesiology and clinical psychologist at the Center for Obesity Research and Education at Temple University.
Napolitano and her team surveyed data collected from 278 women, both normal weight and obese, enrolled in a year-long physical activity encouragement study. At baseline, and 3- and 12-month follow up tests, all participants were administered a questionnaire to determine what factors kept them from getting exercise, including:
- Fear of failure;
- Fear of injury;
- Perceived poor health
- Having minor aches or pains
- Feeling too overweight to exercise.
At all time points, obese women reported greater barriers to being active than normal-weight women. For obese women, barriers they identified at the beginning of the study predicted how much or how little they would be exercising at the 12-month follow-up.
“These might sound like excuses to some people, but for those who have these aversions, they’re real problems,” said Napolitano.
She theorizes that tailoring programs to maneuver around these barriers is the key to curbing some of that aversion and improving adherence to a weight loss goal. She cites the popular Curves® gyms as a step in the right direction because they offer a comforting, welcoming environment for women to exercise in.
“There is an underlying attitude about weight loss, that it’s easy if you just eat less and exercise more,” she said. “But if losing weight were easy, we wouldn’t have the obesity epidemic we have today.”
The study was co-authored by Kelley Borradaile, research assistant professor of public health at the Center for Obesity Research and Education at Temple University. Funding for this research was provided by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and assistance from the American Heart Association.